Kilcoyne Redwood Inn

Reviews

• Jay K.

  star star star star star 12 September 2026

  Ordered from this restaurant on DoorDash.  I'm here on business from Ohio for a few months so I've never heard of this place before. (I've also never written a restaurant review before, so that should tell you something). But I was in the mood for wings and this place had em!  First I had to get some information... so I looked them up online and saw that their wings look pretty good but also saw that on their menu you can get tots instead of fries. On DoorDash it only gives you the option for fries with the wing combo so I got that and on a whim added in the additional notes I wrote "lots and lots of ranch please please please.   Also tots instead of fries if possible".    And wouldn't ya know BOOM! Opened it as soon as it was delivered;  4 nice sized cups of ranch.... AND TOTS!  Again.. I usually don't write reviews but just by what may seem like a small amount of extra effort for a restaurant made my night and showed that the employees here have a genuine appreciation for their customers and great attention to detail!  Love it!   And I haven't even tried to food yet.      
  
  Update; tried it... and it's amazing.     Thanks Kilcoyne!

• Suzanne C.

  star star star star_border star_border 9 September 2026

  Great neighborhood spot. They have a small dining area. Tables are really crammed into a tiny area. It's an effort getting in and out of your chair.  The bar is packed.
  
  That being said, fish fry is delicious! The cod is hot, crispy, and delicious. It's served with red skin potatoes, vegetables, cole slaw, and a dinner roll. The cost is very reasonable.
  
  This reminds me of Cheers where everyone knows your name. If they could fix the crammed dining room, I'd give this place 5 stars. But for now, 2 stars for atmosphere, and 5 for food.

• Bobby B.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 6 September 2026

  I wish I could give this place a -1 score. I came in for a drink after work. (I am a member of the LGBT community) I was wearing a dress. And I immediately felt judged. Bar tender was very rude and did not compliment my dress (it was stunning) very disappointed. Will take my business to old Munich as the dribks are far better and they know how to treat a gal.

• Karen R.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 31 August 2026

  warning:
  kitchen closes at 8....
  I pulled into the parking lot.  Every single employee was outside, by a side door, smoking!!!
  I walked in. NOT A PERSON IN SIGHT.
  one of the smokers popped in, and I asked her, IS THE  KITCHEN STILL OPEN??
  she said, NO.
  
  Then please post that on your YELP page!! Because it says you are open til 11. If the kitchen closes earlier, you could have posted that. And I didn't have to waste  my time getting here.

• Erica S.

  star star star star star 26 August 2026

  We have been hanging out here for years.  Owner and bar tenders are great!  Atmosphere fun with plenty of TVs and juke box.  Everything on the menu is delicious.  Fish fry and Lobster boils are awesome!